ACCC and News Corp vs Google and Facebook

ACCC and News Corp vs Google and Facebook
  • Aug 20, 2020

ACCC and News Corp vs Google and Facebook

How misplaced is the pressure on the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) watchdog from news organisations such as News Corp to force Google into paying News Corp for the privilege of Google directing search engine traffic towards News Corp’s online platforms and articles through rankings on web searches?

It's bizarre given web searches on many of the largest news platforms like News Corp lead us to a user-pay firewall anyway.

So it's debateable whether News Corp and others should even be included in Google search engine results in the first place, let alone Google having to give financial concessions or payments to News Corp for directing potential users or customers to News Corp products and therefore News Corp advertisers.

Wouldn't it be better if all (mainly foreign) news platforms and all social media (digital) platforms just paid a fair share of tax in Australia?

"Google Australia reaped over $1 billion in total revenue, but paid just $37 million in tax"
source au.finance.Yahoo.com

"News Australia Holdings revenue over 5 years = $13.9B, taxable income = $246M"
source https://twitter.com/michaelwestbiz/status/1215481330072313856

ABC Radio National Download This Show

Check 8.22 - 22.27 of Episode Apple vs Epic, Google vs ACCC

Counter Threat

As a counter threat to the ACCC's perceived interference, Google warns:

"[you] could expect dramatically worse, Google searches and YouTube responses"

ABC Radio National Download This Show Google vs ACCC

However this threat by Google appears to be largely designed to get the Google and especially the YouTube user base fighting Google's case for them through a social media campaign, backlash and petition against the ACCC and proposed legislation.

Change.Org petition – August 2020:

#OurYouTube
The Australian Government has proposed legislation which, if enacted, will enable large news publishers to effectively suppress any and all content they disagree with.
The bill is called the "News Media Bargaining Code" — and it must be stopped immediately.
As it stands, this proposed bill is an assault on Australia's democracy.
If online platforms like YouTube and Google are legally mandated to disclose the inner workings of their systems to large news publishers, then Parliament would effectively be enabling these large news publishers to unfairly rank their content at the top of the YouTube and Google search results.
As a direct result, large news corporations would effectively be able to suppress articles, videos, opinions, ideas, and all other online content they disagree with (like videos from YouTube creators, for example).
If that wasn't dangerous enough, the proposed law also jeopardizes the privacy rights of YouTube viewers by requiring that YouTube hand-over vast amounts of private user-data to these large news companies.

Google also claims:

"They [News Corp] want a few other things so they want for example, Google and Facebook to give media publishers 28 days notice if they're going to change that sort of algorithms in a way that might affect the display of news."

ABC Radio National Download This Show Google vs ACCC

Special Sauce

Google's 'special sauce' is its algorithms that place the most worthy content high up on its search pages. So this would be a world-first precedent where certain organisations such as News Corp under the direction of the Australian Government are to be given 'free kicks' that are not necessarily merited, while their corporate competitors are awarded none, no matter how good their product.

Then again, major multinational News organisations already have a history of using technology to benefit their bottom lines without any recognition of or concerns regarding the legality, ethics or fairness of such tactics - take for instance their illegal hacking of mobile phones of people living and dead as ‘click bait' to feed News Corp's news cycle.

Phone Hacking

"The News International phone-hacking scandal was a controversy involving the now-defunct News of the World and other British newspapers owned by Rupert Murdoch."
source a https://en.wikipedia.org/

So these 'mobs' involved in phone hacking scandals are now seeking Australian Government assistance to access and control a competitor's Intellectual Property?

"you need to be a media publisher of a certain size to bargain full stop"

ABC Radio National Download This Show Google vs ACCC

These proposals to make Google pay are not going to help small, local media producers. They are just for the big media players, questionably in consort with a government whose political party wing has arguably benefited greatly from News Corp's media bias.

ABC Media Watch 2020 - Episode 30
Making big tech pay (31 Aug)

https://www.abc.net.au/mediawatch/episodes/google/12612756

Pay Fair Share of Tax on Sales Revenue

How about the 'novel' idea of making News Corp, Google (including Youtube) and other digital platforms - Apple, Facebook, Amazon, Netflix, etc - just pay their fair share of tax on their revenue from sales in Australia?

Google Search Featured Snippet

Google Australia's latest financial accounts show it paid almost $100 million in tax in 2019, which is far higher than previous years.

But the tax paid on profits needs to be considered in the context that the company did not count $4.8 billion in gross revenue locally, mostly from advertising.

The Federal Government's tougher anti-avoidance laws, aimed at recouping more tax from multinationals, saw a number of multinationals restructure their tax affairs to pay more tax locally than they have in past years.

However, the laws have not been able to stop the legal practice of companies like Facebook and Google channelling hefty amounts of advertising revenue via low-tax countries such as Singapore.

This is why the OECD, together with the G20, has been working on a plan to tax digital companies.

But that work has been delayed due to the coronavirus pandemic, and there are fears it could take years before governments agree on, and implement, a solution.

The delay has resulted in some countries already moving to tax digital companies' sales, rather than their profits, in a huge departure from long-standing tax principles.

Google has long considered itself merely as "agent" facilitating sales locally.

This means that while Google Australia counts the commission it earns on its lucrative advertising sales as revenue, the majority gets attributed through Singapore.

Nassim Khadem, 18 May 2020 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-05-18/google-pays-more-tax-but-still-makes-billions-in-singapore/12254448

Trump Threatens France

Google's Vice President - government affairs and public policy - Karan Bhatia, has argued the tech giant supports the move toward a new global framework for how multinational companies are taxed.

But he has also warned a feud between the United States and France over taxing US tech giants could extend more widely.

In July, the French Senate approved a 3 per cent levy that will apply to revenue from digital services earned in France by companies with more than 25 million Euros in French revenue and 750 million Euros worldwide.

The tax, widely referred to as the GAFA tax, which stands for Google, Apple, Facebook, and Amazon, was expected by France's Finance Ministry to raise 500 million Euros a year.

The Washington-based Tax Foundation's Daniel Bunn thinks the OECD delay raises the potential for governments to move ahead with unilateral measures.

"A tax and trade war driven by those unilateral measures would be incredibly harmful to the global economy...The back-and-forth between the United States and France … may return with a vengeance." France's unilateral move invited a strong backlash from the US, with President Donald Trump threatening America would retaliate by imposing tariffs on French wine.

Google Search Results - increasingly taking you nowhere

While Google's revenue from advertisers continues to increase, you may put in a search question regarding an historical event; or request scientific and technical information on a specific topic; or attempt to clarify a disputed fact; or pose a general knowledge question in your search and all that 'pops up' is a snippet of information in a Google answer to your question and perhaps a reference to the source of that information.

However, Google does not direct you to the actual website that is the source of the information. That particular website creator misses out on a click-through or visitor to their website but as they are not paying Google to advertise their site, this seems of little concern to Google.

"interesting to think about Google's sort of history of using its own platform to lobby and be an activist I think this is the first time we've seen such a thing in Australia"

"... Google is obviously hoping that YouTubers around the world have even asked international YouTube creators to make submissions to the ACCC which is an interesting move."

"...I don't quite know who would be mobilized for Facebook in quite the same way, they don't have a creative platform that has enough goodwill to write letters and submit them to a competition regulator in Australia"

ABC Radio National Download This Show Google vs ACCC

Facebook respond with an audio statement

refer ABC Radio National Facebook's threats 'abuse of monopoly power', Nine boss says

Audio statement Facebook 1st Sep 2020

"This is absolutely not our first choice"

Hal Crawford, ex news boss at ninemsn: content, social media and PR advice.

"in terms of the benefits facebook derive from it, they do get some benefit, it is just one small part of the content Facebook has and I think that is a perspective the news industry does not really have."

"If we are going to tax Google and Facebook let's be honest about that and tax them and redistribute that money."

"I don't think this legislation is good at all."
source: ABC RN 3rd Sep 2020

Hal Crawford RN Breakfast 3rd Sep 2020

"I don't think this legislation is good at all"

Conclusion

There are some significant issues with Google - however the notion of handing over Google revenue to a company like News Corp, with its history of bias and right-wing reporting, phone hacking scandals, denial of climate change and at times, racist and misogynist ideologies in its editorials, does not sit well for many. News Corp are simply not good enough as global citizens to warrant this kind of financial 'windfall' through the instrument of the Australian Government.

All digital platforms operating in Australia who derive revenue from advertising in Australia and from sales to Australians should be held legally accountable to pay their fair amount of tax in Australia.

Climate Change

Other Articles

Aug 7, 2020 YouTube Tips and Shortcuts
Jun 23, 2020 ADELAIDE HILLS WINERIES
Jun 1, 2020 Web Video Marketing
May 20, 2020 Is that car oil leak serious?
May 14, 2020 Need a Motor Vehicle Accident Lawyer?
May 12, 2020 A kid in a lolly shop
Apr 21, 2020 River Cruise Gold Coast
Apr 14, 2020 Humans need ants to survive
Mar 31, 2020 Online Strategies for COVID-19
Feb 10, 2020 SEO Competitor Analysis
Jan 8, 2020 Writing for SEO
Jan 6, 2020 Influential Climate Change Journalists
Dec 13, 2019 Issues with Wordpress
Dec 4, 2019 Corporate Governance and Embracing the Web
Oct 9, 2019 SEO Tools for Leverage
Sep 5, 2019 Is Your Home Killing You or just making you sick?
Aug 28, 2019 Anxiety as a Contagion
Aug 22, 2019 HAPPINESS - Why Should We Believe Hilda?
Aug 12, 2019 What Communication Style Do You Use?
Aug 7, 2019 Telling your story
Jul 15, 2019 Business for Sale - Gold Coast
Jul 9, 2019 NDIS Support Coordination
Jun 18, 2019 Counselling De-Mystifying the Psycho in Therapy
Jun 6, 2019 How does NDIS pricing work?
May 14, 2019 INSPECTIONS Buildings, Pests and Electrical
Mar 15, 2019 Memorial Stationary
Mar 5, 2019 The Renewable Energy Race
Feb 14, 2019 PDF - Perfect Document Format
Feb 11, 2019 Climate Change, Power and Politics
Jan 31, 2019 Built to Rent
Jan 14, 2019 Swimming Pool Dreaming
Jan 8, 2019 The Moving Story of Max & Co.
Dec 31, 2018 Finding your core
Oct 9, 2018 Anatomy of a local Google Search
Sep 19, 2018 A French Affair and Dangerous Liaisons
Sep 17, 2018 Break-even Analysis for Bookkeeping
Aug 23, 2018 Recycled Timber Architecture Features
Aug 9, 2018 The Un-natural Art of the Wheel
Aug 3, 2018 How much should you spend on a website?
Jul 24, 2018 A Brief History of Kimono and Obi
Jul 11, 2018 Southport Mechanic
Jul 11, 2018 What do we mean by home automation?
Jun 6, 2018 Seeing Red over Cola
Jun 4, 2018 TERMITES - PLAYING THE GAME
May 28, 2018 Why a Multi-Skilled SEO offers better value
May 11, 2018 How does the DREAM turn into a SCREAM?
May 7, 2018 The Alarming History of Geese, Dogs and Bells
Apr 5, 2018 Air Spider
Mar 13, 2018 Planting a hedge fence
Feb 9, 2018 Life Saving Tyre Accessories
Feb 6, 2018 The bakers oven stops
Dec 6, 2017 Relationship Counselling - the volatile couple
Oct 25, 2017 Plumbing, the Ancient Art of Managing Water
Oct 11, 2017 The Secret Life of Micropiles
Sep 29, 2017 Foundation Underpinning
Sep 8, 2017 Termites the secretive pest
Sep 7, 2017 Sharing your Google Analytics
Sep 5, 2017 Website speed test claims put to the test
Aug 23, 2017 Custom Timber Dining Tables
Jun 23, 2017 Kitchen Renovation Alfresco BBQ
Jun 12, 2017 Hire a photo booth
May 10, 2017 My Site Dropped out of Google
Apr 20, 2017 Recycled Timber comes with a story
Apr 8, 2017 Light Up Your Home
Dec 12, 2016 Evolving eCommerce with SEO
Dec 5, 2016 Image Manager 4 Released
Oct 14, 2016 Classic Gold Coast
Sep 26, 2016 Techheads who can market
Sep 9, 2016 Issues with childhood photography
Aug 30, 2016 Never Make an Impulse Appliance Purchase
Aug 15, 2016 Using the potential of YouTube
Aug 2, 2016 How to add a review to Google Places
Jul 26, 2016 Servicing your air-conditioner
Jul 22, 2016 Eco-friendly Home Building
Jun 13, 2016 Timber Floors
May 13, 2016 Timber Furniture Gold Coast
Apr 13, 2016 Interactive Charts
Feb 18, 2016 Ideas for creating passive income
Jan 29, 2016 Better Childhood Photography
Dec 30, 2015 Gold Coast Real Estate
Nov 20, 2015 Feed-in Solar Tariffs Queensland
Nov 5, 2015 Kindergarten Photographers
Sep 23, 2015 Low Budget High Impact Web Videos
Sep 8, 2015 Pool Inspection Laws Queensland
Jul 23, 2015 Protection against power surges
Jul 13, 2015 Intelligent Security Systems
Jun 17, 2015 Advanced Security Cameras
Jan 15, 2015 Is your security provider licensed?
Jan 6, 2015 Inspired by Necessity
Dec 7, 2014 Social Media vs SEO for sales generation
Nov 1, 2014 Responsive Websites vs a Mobile version
Sep 8, 2014 Simplify Writing - Get that job
Apr 8, 2014 Cockroaches like BBQs too
Mar 27, 2014 Admin System Mark 3
Feb 12, 2014 HTML5 improving SEO and Social Interaction
Jan 17, 2014 TV Commercials with impact - on time
Dec 2, 2013 Negative SEO
Nov 29, 2013 A flexible e-mail system
Nov 13, 2013 Social Media Strategies for SEO
Oct 15, 2013 Web Video Production
Sep 26, 2013 Soft drinks can damage your teeth?
Aug 29, 2013 Haridresser Gold Coast
Aug 26, 2013 Jet Boat Ride Gold Coast
Aug 6, 2013 Dental Site Videos
Aug 3, 2013 Gold Coast Tradesman Directory
Jul 2, 2013 Creating audio for your site via your iPhone
Apr 23, 2013 Yellow Pages Google Partnership Unfair
Aug 17, 2012 Facebook Account Security
Jul 6, 2012 Gold Coast a great place to Study
Dec 22, 2011 New Real Estate System
Oct 17, 2011 Managing your domains a quick guide
Apr 4, 2011 Our Facebook Application
Feb 1, 2011 Video Marketing
Jan 5, 2011 Questions to ask your web developer
Dec 28, 2010 Surfboard for sale site launched
Dec 28, 2010 Health and Fitness sites
Dec 9, 2010 Why is my content management system so slow?
Nov 26, 2010 Google now includes local places results
Oct 31, 2010 Getting Listed on Google Places very important
Oct 19, 2010 Security Systems site launched
Sep 28, 2010 Google Personalized Searches
Sep 13, 2010 Web Marketing To Green or Not to Green? Beware!
Sep 9, 2010 Jet ski or Jet boat Gold Coast
Jul 19, 2010 Java Web Hosting
Jul 7, 2010 Assess your eCommerce opportunities
Jun 11, 2010 DIY SEO
May 26, 2010 Planning a website
Apr 22, 2010 Enhanced Email Marketing Tool for your website
Apr 12, 2010 Site Speed is important for Google
Mar 26, 2010 360 degree Panoramas + Google Maps

A Gold Coast SEO and Web Developer